Four Questions that Undermine Social Media: Can You Answer What Amanda Chapel Has Posed?
The anonymous Twitter account @amandachapel takes great joy in critiquing social media luminaries and serving as a contrarian voice in the echo chamber of social media. While this person can be caustic and take personal shots at people, I find the industry commentary and most of her questions to be of value.
Just this morning she posed four questions on Twitter that I think are worth exploring in greater detail. Since @amandachapel doesn’t maintain an active blog, I’ll take the initiative to host the discussion here. I just ask that everyone maintains a civil discourse here. If you violate that tenet, I’ll remove your comments.
Here goes:
QUESTION: 1. What is the basis of the belief that indiscriminate empowerment is a good thing?
QUESTION: 2. What is the basis of the belief that indiscriminate communications is a good thing?
QUESTION: 3. What’s the basis for the belief that the unleashed unfettered unencumbered social groupings that form online are a good thing?
QUESTION: 4. What are the economic consequences of a society devoid of the ability to produce scale?
Feel free to answer any or all of these.
Find me on Twitter: @scottyhendo
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
June 8th, 2009 at 2:40 pm
Interesting. I suppose she(?) assumes anyone who ascribes any value to the social web believes everything implied in the questions…
Not that indiscriminate empowerment, communications and community-forming capability are necessarily _bad_–unless you’re a member of the ruling party in North Korea. And social networking tools impede our ability to produce scale? Gosh, wasn’t aware of that one. Learn something new every day.